Reading between the red flags

BookTok made reading trendy, but its influence isn’t always swoon-worthy

Editors note: This article discusses fictional depictions of sexual violence.

On Sept. 11, SeaWorld Orlando introduced a new Halloween attraction called Just One More Chapter, inviting visitors to ogle men in black outfits with spray-painted abs. One thing the SeaWorld team did succeed at was making a truly terrifying event, though probably not for the reasons they intended. The attraction was inspired by an internet phenomenon known as BookTok, a corner of TikTok dedicated to discussing, recommending, and reviewing books. It has become particularly influential among younger readers, with certain authors and genres gaining enormous popularity through viral videos.

Romance novels, particularly dark romance, have become especially popular among BookTok creators and readers. Unlike many conventional romance novels, dark romance explores more disturbing dynamics, often involving obsession, violence, manipulation, and questionable consent. This popularity has also coincided with a peculiar subculture of men wearing masks, biker helmets, and black outfits in bizarre, often suggestive videos aimed at the so-called ‘BookTok girlies’ — a trend SeaWorld drew on for its attraction. One example from TikTok creator @unholy_incubus features him wearing a Scream mask and dragging a woman through the woods by her ankle. Comments included “to whoever is being dragged: how does it feel to live my dream” and “how do I find myself a dark romance man.”

I understand that fictional fantasies and real-life relationship expectations are two different things, but I find the romanticization of sexual violence difficult to defend. Haunting Adeline by H.D. Carlton is a popular dark-romance novel containing repeated depictions of rape, with the perpetrator ultimately presented as the romantic lead. At one point, the protagonist acknowledges that she would be sleeping with “a man who has forced himself on me on several occasions.” There is a difference between exploring disturbing subject matter and packaging sexual violence as an aspirational romance. And when this content inspires real-world men to dress up as fictional stalkers for social media and family-friendly marine parks, perhaps we can admit that the whole thing is a little concerning.

Some adult romance novels popular on BookTok have cute cartoon-style covers that can make their adult content difficult to identify. TikTok creator @lucieslibrary warned parents about Hannah Grace’s Icebreaker and Wildfire, saying the books “look so innocent” despite containing explicit sexual content. This resembles criticism of adult animation based on the assumption that anything illustrated must be intended for children. I believe that cartoon covers aren’t inherently a problem, but publishers should make intended audiences clearer through content warnings, age ratings, and adult-fiction sections in bookstores. Bookstores should also consider where they display these titles. At the Chapters location in Moncton, I noticed a display labelled “Spicy Romance” that included titles such as Haunting Adeline in front of the section designated for ages 13 and up. The display was in the same corner as the 13+ section, with no clear separation between the two, making it reasonably easy to mistake this display as part of the younger reading section.

Another issue is when reading becomes more about collecting and creating content than actually engaging with books. There’s a popular saying on BookTok that “buying books and reading books are two different hobbies.” Hunting down special editions, collecting merchandise, and building an aesthetically pleasing bookshelf really can make collecting books as much of a hobby as reading them.

BookTok creator @limmadi8 has discussed creators promoting books they have never read, while X user @wtflanksteak called out the practice of people reading only dialogue in books. Emotional reaction videos have also become popular, with some creators filming themselves crying, giving “silent reviews” through facial expressions, or listing a novel’s tropes without discussing its writing, characters, or plot. There’s nothing wrong with being emotional about a book, but when reviews are reduced solely to reactions, it’s difficult to tell what the book is actually about. Books like Haunting Adeline and Icebreaker are written for adult audiences, but short reaction videos don’t always make that clear. Publisher relationships can further complicate recommendations. Canada’s Competition Bureau says influencers should disclose connections such as free products, payments, and discounts. Viewers deserve to know when an enthusiastic recommendation might also be marketing, particularly when creators have received free books from publishers, though not all creators disclose this.

Despite these criticisms, I hesitate to be too harsh on BookTok. As an avid reader myself, I think it’s fantastic that BookTok encourages people to pick up a book. For example, Madeline Miller’s The Song of Achilles, originally published in 2011, experienced a remarkable resurgence after gaining popularity on BookTok; by 2022, the novel had received an estimated two-million-copy sales boost. BookNet Canada’s research into 20 popular BookTok backlist titles, including The Song of Achilles, The Cruel Prince, and We Were Liars, found that their combined Canadian print sales increased by over 1,000 per cent between July 2019 and June 2022.

I think certain measures of criticism directed at the BookTok community are unfair. Some of it comes from thinly veiled literary elitism, as though enjoying popular fantasy novels disqualifies someone from being a real reader. In a 2023 Dazed article, creator @bibliobushra pointed out how ridiculous it was that reading “only” one book a month could get someone labelled “not a real reader.”

Additionally, romance has historically been treated as frivolous, formulaic, and intellectually inferior, despite being one of the publishing industry’s most commercially successful genres. That success makes it worth questioning why books predominantly enjoyed by women attract so much contempt. A 2023 study published in Poetics found that romance, among other feminized genres, was less likely to receive coverage from mainstream literary critics. Some romance novels are indeed poorly written, but every genre naturally has its duds. It would be difficult to argue that Jane Austen’s novels are inferior simply because romance plays such a central role in them. Criticizing individual books is one thing, but dismissing an entire genre because its audience is predominantly female is hardly a legitimate critique.

BookTok creators and readers have introduced people to new books, revived interest in older titles, and given authors new audiences. I don’t want to discourage any of that, particularly when so much of the criticism directed at popular reading comes from elitist and misogynistic viewpoints. But encouraging people to read and encouraging them to consume are two different things. When books become products to collect, recommendations become marketing opportunities, reviews offer little actual information, and sexual violence is repackaged as something desirable, we should be questioning what messages are being spread. Enjoying dark fiction isn’t inherently harmful, but that doesn’t mean we should ignore how sexual violence is portrayed or marketed. I believe that we should be able to celebrate a platform that gets people reading while still questioning parts of the culture it has created.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Articles